Johnny Malloy’s offers an award winning menu that features Pizza, Ribs, Wings and Sandwiches. Order online for delivery or carryout.


Combo Platter 18.99
A sampling of our famous wings, mozzarella sticks, BBQ ribs, potato skins and chicken fingers

Boneless Wings or Tenders 7.99
1/2lb Lightly breaded chicken tossed in your favorite wing sauce

Loaded Nachos 9.99
Pile it on, ground beef, cheese, sour cream, black olives, green peppers, onions & pepper rings

Loaded Fries 6.99
Our fresh cut French fries smothered w/cheese & bacon

NEW | Spicy Hot French Fries Basket  5.99

Cheesy Breadsticks 4.99
Served with marinara sauce

Jumbo Johnny’s 7.99
Soft Pretzel Sticks Served with Beer Cheese sauce

Mussels 8.99 per lb.
Served with our famous garlic butter sauce

Mozzarella Sticks  8.99 
Served with marinara dipping sauce 

NEW | Fried Green Tomatoes 8.99 
Fiesta style 

Your choice of steak, cheese or chicken, on a tortilla shell served w/ sour cream
w/Cheese 7.99
w/Chicken or Steak 9.99

NEW | Rueben Rolls 9.99
Served with 1000 Island and horsey sauce 

Breaded Mushrooms 6.99

Breaded Green beans 6.99
Served with cool buffalo

Potato Skins 7.99
Loaded w/ bacon & cheese

Basket of Onion Rings 7.99
Thick cut, beer battered, double dipped and seasoned, piled high and served with cool buffalo dipping sauce

Deep Fried Pickles 6.99
With horsey sauce

Garlic Bread 3.99
With cheese 4.99

Basket of Balls 8.99
1/2oz homemade meatballs tossed our Texas sweet BBQ sauce or any of our award-winning sauces

Johnny Bites 7.99
Pretzel bites tossed in garlic sauce served with cheese sauce 

NEW | Pepperoni Bites 5.99
Sweet and spicy served with marinara sauce 


Add $1 for cheese, $1 for egg or $1 for bacon

Dressings: Bleu Cheese, Buttermilk Ranch, French, Poppy Seed, Honey Mustard, Italian, Creamy Italian, Low Fat Italian, Balsamic Vinaigrette

Chef 8.99
Meat this favorite – ham, salami, pepperoni, pepperoncini & red ripe tomatoes

Grilled Chicken 8.99
Grilled chicken breast, pepperoncini and red ripe tomatoes

Cobb Salad 10.99
Chopped mixed greens, bacon, chicken, tomato, eggs, black olives, cucumber and crumbled bleu cheese

Caesar 7.99
Romaine and croutons served with creamy Caesar dressing
with grilled chicken 9.99

Caprese Salad 8.99
Fresh mozzarella slices with juicy tomato slices. onions, fresh basil, and our homemade balsamic vinaigrette dressing…classic

Garden 6.99 (Half order 4.99)
Lettuce serve you: tomato, cucumber and pepperoncini


5 Wings 5.99
10 Wings 10.99
Bleu Cheese, Ranch & Celery (extra charge)

Regular or Healthy Baked
1/2lb  8.99

30 Wings Sampler 29.99
5 different sauces, includes celery, 1 ranch, 1 blue cheese

Regular Sauces

  • Teriyaki
  • Honey Mustard 
  • Garlic Parmesan
  • Honey Bourbon
  • Honey Bourbon BBQ
  • Texas Sweet BBQ
  • Original BBQ
  • Cool Buffalo
  • Mild Buffalo
  • Garlic Buffalo
  • Spicy Teriyaki
  • Spicy Honey Mustard
  • Hot BBQ
  • Hot Garlic Buffalo
  • Hot Buffalo
  • Hot Hot Hot!

Dry Rub Flavors

  • Chipotle Smoke
  • Lemon Pepper
  • Rotisserie
  • Southern Spice

Choose from Traditional or Thin Crust & Original, Sweet, Spicy, Garlic Butter, Marinara or BBQ sauce

SMALL 8: $6.99 . | Additional standard topping $1.00 each
MEDIUM 12: $9.99 | Additional standard topping $1.25 each
LARGE 14: $12.99 | Additional standard topping $1.50 each
X-LARGE 16: $14.99 | Additional standard topping $1.75 each
SHEET PIZZA: $21.50 | Additional standard topping $3.50 each

Standard Toppings: Pepperoni, Mushrooms, Green Peppers, Onions, Sausage, Tomatoes, Black or Green Olives, Ham, Anchovies, Pepperoncini, Homemade Meatballs, Bacon, Pepper Rings, Pineapple

Premium Toppings: (Standard Topping charge plus $1) Chicken, Extra Provolone Cheese, Cheddar Cheese


Small 8: $11.99
Medium 12: $15.99
Large 14: $17.99
X-Large 16: $21.99

BBQ Rib Pizza
Award Winning! With our famous Geppetto’s BBQ sauce, boneless rib meat & onion, topped with provolone & cheddar

Meat Feast
Feast your eyes on generous portions of pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ham & homemade meatballs

Pepperoni Feast
Extra pepperoni with lots and lots of cheese

Let’s Go To Hawaii
Say aloha to a delicious combo of ham, bacon and pineapple with special island spices

Loaded Potato Pizza
Loaded with potato, ranch & bacon cheddar/provolone mix & a touch of garlic butter

NEW | Clevelander
Just like Cleveland – sometimes it’s backwards…cheese, pepperoni and sauce on top

BBQ Chicken
Award winning Geppetto’s sauce covering tender chicken chunks with provolone & cheddar

Buffalo Boneless Chicken
Chicken breast, provolone cheese, crumbled bleu cheese, and buffalo sauce

Garden of Eden
Veg out on mushrooms, onions, green peppers, black olives & fresh diced tomatoes

Mexican Fiesta
A south of the border taco sauce, taco meat, onions, green peppers, olives, tomatoes, tortilla chips and two cheeses

Fresh basil, fresh tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, onion, parsley, garlic & oregano

Philly Cheesesteak
Top round steak, onions, green peppers, mushrooms, and cheese and cheese and cheese


St. Louis style pork ribs basted in our award winning BBQ sauce
Small Dinner $13.99
1/4 slab, 2 sides, and a roll
Big Dinner $19.99
2/3 slab, 2 sides, and a roll

Rib & Chicken Combo  $19.99
4 tasty rib bones and 2 pieces of chicken served with choice of 2 sides

Breaded Shrimp Dinner  $12.99
Served with 2 sides and a roll

Fish & Chips  $12.99
Try this house favorite! Lightly breaded cod served with French Fries and cole slaw

Chicken Parmesan  $12.99
Served with penne. Lightly breaded chicken breast topped with tomato, melted provolone, & marinara

Breaded Lake Perch  $18.99
Breaded and fried to a golden brown, served with French fries and cole slaw

Pierogi Dinner $8.99
5 delicious potato and cheese filled drizzled with sauteed onions servered with sour cream and applesauce 

Spaghetti or Penne $7.99
With our homemade marinara sauce
Add 1 topping for 2.50 mushrooms, meat sauce, meatball or Italian sausage

Grilled Chicken Breast  $14.99
2 large skinless boneless grilled chicken breasts served BBQ, southern spice, or plain. Includes choice of 2 sides. 

Chicken Fingers
Includes choice of 2 sides
2 Piece 9.99
4 Piece 12.99

Orignal Mac ‘n Cheese Bake $9.99
Cavatappi noodles smothered in our homemade creamy 3 cheeses concoction!

Chipotle Chicken  Bake $12.99
Cavatappi noodles smothered in our homemade creamy 3 cheeses concoction with chicken breast and some smokey goodness

Sausage and Peppers  $9.99
This Irishman knows the importance of an Italian classics – 2 links tossed with onions and peppers sauteed to perfection

w/ two toppings  $9.99
Additional Toppings  $1.50
Toppings are the same as listed in the pizza section

SIDES $3.99
Fresh Cut French Fries / Cole Slaw / Green Beans  / Homemade Mac & Cheese / Potato Chips / Baked Beans / Onion Rings / Tater Tots

Side of Steak Fries 5.00


** All sandwiches are priced a la carte **  Add $1 for any side, $2 for onion rings, $3 for steak fries

NEW | The Criminal  $8.99
Grilled cheese on Texas Toast with 2 over easy (runny) eggs… Don’t ask for the eggs dry, we won’t ruin a great sandwich.

Italian Meatball  $9.99
Homemade Italian meatballs loaded with sauce and provolone cheese

Italian Sausage  $9.99
Fresh sausage topped with grilled green peppers and onion or provolone cheese & spaghetti sauce

Corned Beef  Sandwich $10.99
Stacked high and proud 

Dublin Dip $10.99
Thinly sliced ribeye, served on a hoagie bun with cheese and Au Jus

NEW | Dublin Dunk $10.99
Messy version of the Dublin Dip – we dare you not to use a fork

Philly Cheese Steak $10.99
Thinly sliced ribeye grilled with peppers, onions & mushrooms smothered with cheese

Chicken Philly $10.99
Chicken grilled with peppers, onions & mushrooms smothered with cheese

West Side Grill $9.49
Charbroiled chicken breast topped with mushrooms, bacon & melted mozzarella cheese, served on a bun with lettuce & tomato

Spicy Buffalo Chicken $9.49
Dipped in mild buffalo sauce and served with lettuce & tomato

NEW | Cover 2 Defense $8.99
2 hot dogs piled high with chili and cheese

Chicken Parmesan $9.49
Italian chicken breast covered in provolone cheese and marinara sauce

Hoagie $9.99 (hot or cold)
Loaded with ham, salami, pepperoni, cheese, lettuce & tomato

Gyro $8.99
Grilled lamb with tomatoes, onions & cucumber served with French Fries

NEW | Chicken Cordon Blue $8.99
Bakes chicken with fresh sliced ham and swiss with a side of our homemade dijon honey mustard


** All burgers are priced a la cart priced – add $1 for any side, $2 for onion rings, $3 for steak fries**

Black and Bleu Burger $9.99
Blackened to perfection with our special Cajun seasoning and topped with bleu cheese dressing

The Malloy Classic $9.99
Half pound of fresh ground chuck topped with melted Swiss, then smothered in grilled onions and sauteed mushrooms

Bourbon Bacon Burger  $9.99
Our Half Pound Burger with cheddar, bacon, & our Southern bourbon glaze

BBQ Burger  $9.99
Half pound of fresh ground chuck drippin’ in Geppetto’s BBQ sauce, then topped with crisp bacon

St. Patty Melt Burger  $9.99
Half pound of fresh ground chuck topped with grilled onions, Swiss cheese on rye bread

All American Burger  $9.99
Half pound of fresh ground chuck topped with bacon and American cheese

Johnny Burger $9.99
Half pound of fresh ground chuck topped with provolone cheese and sauteed mushrooms

Sunny Burger $9.99
Half pound burger with American cheese, bacon and a fried egg

Cleveland Hero $9.99
2 1/4lb patties with salami, lettuce, tomato, onion, special Italian dressing and mayo

NEW | Italiano Burger $10.99
Fried green tomatoes covered with marinara and cheese


** All wraps are priced a la carte **  Add $1 for any side, $2 for onion rings, $3 for steak fries

Chicken Caesar $7.99
Chicken strips, romaine lettuce, croutons & Caesar dressing

Cool Buffalo Chicken $7.99
Chicken tenders spun in our spicy Cool Buffalo sauce and served with lettuce 

OHHH BOY  $7.99
Breaded Shrimp tossed in our bonsai sauce! Wrapped w/lettuce onion & provolone cheese

Spicy Buffalo Chicken $7.99
Chicken tenders spun in our original Buffalo sauce with lettuce & provolone cheese

Breakfast Wrap $7.99
2 fried eggs, potatoes, ham, sausage, bacon, and a dash of hot sauce all wrapped up